Back to bookshelf

Burdens | Scott Alexander 

Appreciation
7
Importance
--
Date Added
8.17.25
TLDR
Humans don’t owe society anything; we were here first. Actively suicidal people always say they feel like a burden. Sometimes the signal here is that you can't trust your brain. But the premise of this question is misguided—our self-worth is not predicated upon our ability to contribute.
2 Cents
--
Tags

I expect I certainly will be [a burden] before I die – I would like there to be in place a crystal-clear understanding that we were here first and society doesn’t get to make us obsolete without owing us something in return.

After that, we will have to predicate our self-worth on something other than being able to “contribute” in the classical sense of the term. Don’t get me wrong, I think contributing something is a valuable goal, and one it’s important to enforce to prevent free-loaders. But it’s a valuable goal at the margins, some people are already heading for the tails, and pretty soon we’ll all be stuck there.

I’m not sure what such a post-contribution value system would look like. It might be based around helping others in less tangible ways, like providing company and cheerfulness and love. It might be a virtue ethics celebrating people unusually good at cultivating traits we value. Or it might be a sort of philosophically-informed hedonism along the lines of Epicurus, where we try to enjoy ourselves in the ways that make us most human.

(Featured in Alexey Guzey's Most Important Slate Star Codex Posts .)